The Ultimate MAC Eyeshadow Guidebook

This is an extensive guidebook I wrote that I'm now leaving here for you to use for free. A good amount of research went into putting this together so I hope you enjoy it! Please use the table of contents below to easily move throughout this post.

Table Of Contents

1. The Top 8 Most Popular MAC Eyeshadow Colors
2. Her Top 10 MAC Eyeshadow Must-Haves (video)
3. MAC Eyeshadow Swatches (video)
4. Where to Find the Best MAC Eyeshadow Combinations
5. MAC Eyeshadow Application Tips and Techniques (video)
6. What Kind of Ingredients Do MAC Eyeshadows Use?
7. MAC Eyeshadow Prices vs Other Brands?
8. 134 MAC Eyeshadow Dupes

The Top 8 Most Popular MAC Eyeshadow Colors

It may be somewhat intimidating to chose a MAC eyeshadow if you aren't familiar with what all of the finishes mean. MAC offers shadows in eight different finishes, and all of them apply and wear differently from each other. To simplify your shopping experience, here's a little bit of insight as to what those finishes mean.

Frost can be intimidating to some people. If you want a youthful, illuminating glow, a frost finish is perfect. There is a downside to frost finishes: if you have fine lines or imperfections around your eye area, a frost finish eyeshadow can settle into them, making them appear more noticeable.

***
Lustre shadows are an extreme version of a frost finish, so you may want to exercise the same caution. If you're a glitter fanatic, there is no better finish than lustre. These shadoows appear to be almost pure, coloured glitter in an eyeshadow form, and work best if used sparingly and in conjunction with other finishes.

***
Matte finish eyeshadows contain no shimmer or glitter of any kind. These shadows most mimic the look of skin which is perfect for more natural looks. MAC's usual matte finish eyeshadows tend to be hit or miss in terms of pigmentation. If you're looking for a bold punch of colour, try Matte[2] finish.

***
Matte[2] are the best of MAC's matte finish shadows. They're soft, and go on without being chalky and offer the most pigmentation without any shimmer or glitter. They're much easier to blend than the normal matte finishes, and come in a far better selection of shades.

***
Satin shadows are neither frosty nor glittery, but provide a reflective, pearlescent sheen. These shadows are a wonderful colour payoff and almost look wet when applied. If you're seeking a sophisticated shine but are afraid of frost finishes, MAC's Satin finish is perfect.

***
Veluxe shadows are the softest, smoothest finish that MAC offers. These are the most pigmented MAC shadows, and they feel like cream to the touch. Soft and rich to the touch, these are the makeup enthusiasts' favourite. Expertly create a natural look with these shadows, which appear airbrushed when applied.

***
Veluxe Pearl shadows are the same as veluxe finish, only with a more dramatic sheen. These are the most metallic out of all of MAC's shadows. These shadows are commonly used for runway shows and fashion events, due to the brilliant way they interact with the light. If you want an expensive look, try a veluxe pearl shadow.

***
Velvet shadows work perfect for everyone, for every occasion. While these colours are not necessarily vivid, they are the easiest way to have a small amount of glow without drawing too much attention to your makeup. If you're trying not to look too made up or wear too much colour, that's what the velvet finish shadows are for.

***

Her Top 10 MAC Eyeshadow Must-Haves

 



MAC Eyeshadow Swatches

 


This is a great video made by Karlasugar.net that shows 100+ different eyeshadow colors. This is one of the best videos on eyeshadow swatches you'll find online. The names might be a little hard to read at first but if you blow it up full size they're a lot easier to read.

MAC Eyeshadow Palette Listings

Here's a few current listings on E-Bay for eyeshadow palettes:


Where to Find the Best MAC Eyeshadow Combinations

 


If you haven't been to macshadowcombos.com yet you're missing out big time! Use the eyeshadow directory so you can navigate easily to just the right colors.

Here's a small taste of what you'll find on the site:

MAC eyeshadows used:

  • Satin Taupe (on lid, below crease)
  • Aquadisiac (crease)
  • Vanilla (blend)
  • Gesso (highlight)

MAC eyeshadows used:

  • Knight Divine (on lid, below crease)
  • Vibrant Grape (crease)
  • Vanilla (blend and highlight)

MAC Eyeshadow Application Tips and Techniques

There's a super-helpful series of videos called "Eyeshadow Application 101" and I've posted parts 1 and 2 here. I highly recommend watching these videos, I'm sure you'll get a bunch of good tips out of them.


Part 1
Part 2

What Kind of Ingredients Do MAC Eyeshadows Use?

An important topic I think very few people ask is what are the MAC eyeshadow ingredients? Here's a quick rundown on what ingredients you're going to find in your eyeshadow.

Talc

Now, the largest ingredient in MAC's eyeshadows is Talc. Talc is actually a naturally occuring mineral which absorbs moisture in and gives the shadow its 'opaqueness'.

Zinc Stearate

This is a zinc soap which actually repels water and adds to the color.

Octyldodecyl Stearoyl Stearate

This is a common ingredient in many cosmetics and skincare products. It forms a barrier against your skin and protects it from H20 loss.

Isostearyl Neopentanoate

This little ingredient keeps the powder bound together in a "caked" form.

Tocopheryl Acetate

This is the scientific name for the common ingredient known as vitamin E.

Caprylyl Glycol

This is a skin conditioner and also serves as a antimicrobial agent which helps fend off bacteria from your skin.

Hexylene Glycol

Hexylene Glycol is a thinning agent and solvent which creates a more spreadable eyeshadow.

Phenoxyethanol

This is a preservative which is used in conjunction with caprylyl glycol.

Silica

Silica is a natural ingredient that you can find in the environment. It's used in eyeshadows as a type of absorbant.

Mica

Mica is added to offer the eyeshadow luster and shine.

Coloring Agents

All kinds of eyeshadows will have their own different coloring agents. These is a harmless ingredient which only adds color to the eyeshadow.

MAC Eyeshadow Prices vs Other Brands?

Typical prices for MAC eyeshadows will cost you arond $15 for eyeshadows that are potted and around $11 for eyeshadows that are in the pan.

One thing worth noting is that MAC eyeshadow prices are relatively on the high end compared to other brands like Maybelline or Revlon. This is because MAC produces some of the best eyeshadows around.

If you're willing to be flexible with what you buy and you might consider taking a look at the MAC eyeshadow dupe list just below.

134 MAC Eyeshadow Dupes

Here's a complete list of Mac Eyeshadow dupes. Please feel free to leave a comment below if I'm missing any from this list!

  1. MAC Wedge =-= M Professionals Taupe
  2. MAC All that Glitters =-= NYX Champagne
  3. MAC Perverted Pearl =-= Milani Silver Bullet
  4. MAC Black Tied =-= Covergirl Shimmering Onyx, Milani Storm, Jane Clubbing
  5. MAC Melody =-= Jane Millionare
  6. MAC Partait Amour =-= Milani Enchantment
  7. MAC Aquadisiac =-= Jane Millionare
  8. MAC Naked Lunch =-= NYX Sahara
  9. MAC Passionate =-= NYX Cherry
  10. MAC Little Madam =-= Milani Illusion
  11. MAC Bamboo Wild and Crazy Wild Guava
  12. MAC Shroom =-= Milani Classic Beige or Jordana's Beige
  13. MAC Passionate:NYX Sunrise/Redhead/Cherry
  14. MAC Soba =-= ULTA Toast
  15. MAC Mulch =-= Milani Java Bean
  16. MAC Vellum =-= M Professionals Opalescent White, Wild and Crazy Lily Song, Milani Moonlight, Max Factor Spotlight Sparkle
  17. MAC Crystal =-= L'Oreal Beauty Queen On-the-Loose
  18. MAC Electric Eel =-= Milani Atlantis
  19. MAC Sketch =-= Milani Marooned
  20. MAC Woodwinked =-= Milani Golden Bronze
  21. MAC Pink Source =-= Milani Taffy
  22. MAC Girl meets Boy:NYX Antique gold
  23. MAC Rose =-= Prestige in Flushed
  24. MAC Fab & Flashy =-= NYX Arica/Golden Orange
  25. MAC Embark =-= Jane Brownie Points, Flirt! Coconutty
  26. MAC Cork =-= NYX Dark Brown
  27. MAC Paradisco =-= Flirt! Feeling Hot
  28. MAC Sky Blue Pigment:NYX Cool Blue
  29. MAC Electric Coral Pigment:NYX Tropical
  30. MAC Parrot =-= ULTA Deep Sea, L'oreal HIP in Showy, NYX Ocean
  31. MAC Blue Brown:L'Oreal HIP Inrepid
  32. MAC Juxt =-= Milani Garden Mist
  33. MAC Beaded =-= NYX Sahara
  34. MAC Sumptuous Olive =-= Milani Antique Gold, ULTA Golden Olive, NYX Herb
  35. MAC Beautiful Iris =-= ULTA Iris
  36. MAC Rose Pro =-= Jame Prom Queen
  37. MAC Shadowy Lady =-= L'oreal HIP duo in Wicked (purple side)
  38. MAC Rose Pigment =-= NYX Flamingo
  39. MAC Creme de Violet =-= ULTA Iris
  40. MAC Midnight Blue =-= Jane Blue Jeans, Prestige Horizon
  41. MAC Lucky Green =-= Wild and Crazy Marquis, NYX lime
  42. MAC Hepcat =-= Prestige Blossom
  43. MAC Quarry =-= Prestige Sandalwood
  44. MAC Pink Freeze =-= Prestige Ballet, Milani Taffy, Cover Girl Pink Chiffon
  45. MAC Stars 'n' Rockets =-= Milani Shock
  46. MAC Going Bananas:NYX Yeallow Pearl
  47. MAC Jewel Blue =-= Jane Eye Zing in Surfer Girl
  48. MAC Silver =-= Milani in Mercury
  49. MAC Camel =-= Revlon Pro Bamboo
  50. MAC Goldmine =-= Prestige Golden Retriever
  51. MAC Band on Blue =-= NYX Lanikai
  52. MAC Paradisco =-= NYX Tropical or CoverGirl Tropical Fusion Quad (orange shade)
  53. MAC Big T =-= NYX Wild Fire
  54. MAC Wedge =-= L'oreal HIP duo in Shady
  55. MAC Vanilla =-= Philosophy Serenity, Wild and Crazy Mist Over Me 3110, Milani Snow Frost
  56. MAC Juxt:NYX Springleaf
  57. MAC Swish =-= Prestige Love
  58. MAC Unreally Blue =-= Milani Blue Jeans
  59. MAC Shadesticks =-= NYX Eyeshadow Wands
  60. MAC Brule =-= Milani Almondine
  61. MAC Jest =-= Milani Peachy Peach, Maybelline Pink Sands, ULTA Bermuda Sand
  62. MAC Pink Venus =-= Milani Taffy
  63. MAC Nylon =-= NYX Barely There
  64. MAC Satin Taupe =-= NYX Root Beer, NYX Iced Mocha, L'oreal HIP Duo in Sassy (taupe shade)
  65. MAC Brill =-= Wild & Crazy Bahama Water
  66. MAC Trax =-= Prestige Flushed, Flirt! Glamourazzi, Milani Desire
  67. MAC Creme de Violet =-= Aromaleigh's Pure Eyes Frost Eyeshadow in Desire
  68. MAC Kicky Blue =-= L'Oreal Holographic Blue
  69. MAC Shroom =-= Jordana Beige, Jane Magic Mushroom, Wet 'n Wild Flirt Shimmer Stick, NYX Bearly There
  70. MAC Dark Soul pigment =-= Jane clubbing
  71. MAC Naked Lunch =-= Wet n' Wild Fine Wink, NYX Aloha
  72. MAC Wondergrass =-= NYX Kiwi
  73. MAC Mineralized Eyeshadow Duo in Two to Glow =-= L'oreal HIP Duo in Flare
  74. MAC Coppering =-= NYX Copper
  75. MAC Sushi Flower =-= Prestige in Love, NYX Cherry
  76. MAC Sable =-= Milani Java Bean
  77. MAC Emote:NYX Taupe
  78. MAC Dementhe =-= Milani Clover
  79. MAC Shale =-= Milani Icy Plum
  80. MAC Vellum =-= Milani Moonlight
  81. MAC Plum Dressing =-= L'oreal HIP duo in Cheeky
  82. MAC Shimmermoss =-= ULTA Luna, NYX Jungle Fever
  83. MAC Sweet Sienna =-= Theshespace.com Gothic Glamour
  84. MAC Sumptuous Olive =-= Milani Antiqued Gold
  85. MAC Coco =-= NYX Beanie
  86. MAC French Gray =-= NYX Iced Mocha
  87. MAC Amber Lights =-= Milani Sun Goddess, NYX Golden
  88. MAC Star n Rockets =-= NYX Luxor
  89. MAC Jest =-= Milani Peachy Peach
  90. MAC Carbon =-= NYX Black
  91. MAC Medowland =-= L'Oreal Wear Infinite in Glistening Sea
  92. MAC Steamy =-= Milani Clover, ULTA Luna
  93. MAC Humid =-= Milani Clover, Ulta Shamrock
  94. MAC Brulee =-= NYX Nude
  95. MAC Hypnotique =-= Prestige Saturn
  96. MAC Sprout =-= Prestige Wasabi, Milani Garden Mist
  97. MAC Little Madame =-= Milani Illusion
  98. MAC D'Bohemia =-= Wild and Crazy Crazy on You, ULTA Knit
  99. MAC Glare =-= Prestige Golden Sun, ULTA Silk
  100. MAC Vapor =-= Prestige Chilly
  101. MAC Steamy =-= Milani Clover
  102. MAC Nylon =-= Milani Classic Beige, TooFaced Glamazon, WnW Cream
  103. MAC Deep Truth =-= Loreal On the Loose in Night Fever
  104. MAC Electra =-= Jane Hi Ho Silver
  105. MAC Satin Taupe =-= Maybelline Silken Taupe, Rimmel Strength, ULTA Twilight,NYX Iced Mocha, NYX Mink Brown, NYX Root beer
  106. MAC Leisure Time =-= L'Oreal OTL in Flash Light
  107. MAC Cranberry:NYX Rust
  108. MAC Amber Lights =-= Milani Sun Goddess, Milani Desert Sun, Prestige Melba, L'Oreal HIP Saucy, NYX Golden
  109. MAC Shadowy Lady =-= Milani Marooned
  110. MAC Black Tied =-= Milani Storm, Prestige Onyx
  111. MAC Mulch =-= Milani Java Bean, L'oreal HIP in Saucy
  112. MAC Dazzleray Pigment =-= NYC Loose Sparkle Eye Dust in Champagne
  113. MAC Guacamole =-= Milani Limbo Lime
  114. MAC Vex =-= Max Factor Mint Matinee
  115. MAC Romping:NYX Hot Pink/Burgundy Pearl, Milani Exotic Berry
  116. MAC Coquette =-= Almay Khaki Eye Gel
  117. MAC Atlas =-= ULTA Silk
  118. MAC Cork =-= M Professinals Soft Brown Eyeshadow, Covergirl Swiss Chocolate
  119. MAC Humid =-= Milani Clover, WnW Sensual Sage, NYX Mermaid
  120. MAC Gorgeous Gold =-= L'oreal's Enlightened Emerald Duo, Dior GoldFusion
  121. MAC Pink Freeze =-= Milani Taffy
  122. MAC Blue Noir =-= Prestige in Ink
  123. MAC Banshee =-= Milani Spice
  124. MAC Parfait Amour:Milani Shock/Enchanment
  125. MAC Nocturnelle =-= Milani Shock, Lancome Contrast
  126. MAC Eyepopping =-= NYX Lime Juice
  127. MAC Pink Vivid Pigment:NYX Hot Pink
  128. MAC Coppering =-= Milani Flare
  129. MAC Cornflower =-= Physician's Formula Virtual Eyes Loose Shadow in Eye-Tech
  130. MAC Vanilla =-= Milani Snow Frost, Cover Girl single in French Vanilla
  131. MAC Electric Eel =-= Milani Atlantis, NYX Irises
  132. MAC Metamorph =-= Rimmel Hope
  133. MAC Nocturnelle =-= Milani Shock
  134. MAC Woodwinked =-= Milani Golden Bronze, L'oreal HIP duo in Wicked (brown side)